The 2025 landscape for Bollywood’s powerhouses, Dharma Productions and Yash Raj Films (YRF), has proven that even the most seasoned gatekeepers of the industry are navigating a “post-formula” world where traditional success is no longer a guarantee.
The year was defined by a startling polarisation of results, suggesting that while these studios have a clear strategy, the execution often feels like a high-stakes gamble rather than a calculated certainty.
For Dharma Productions, the duality of the year was epitomised by the prestige of Homebound and the backlash of Nadaaniyan.
Directed by Neeraj Ghaywan, Homebound emerged as a critical masterpiece, securing a nine-minute standing ovation at Cannes and eventually becoming India’s official entry for the Academy Awards.
Despite its dismal theatrical collection of roughly ₹3 crore, it restored Dharma’s reputation as a champion of “vital” cinema, proving that Karan Johar and creative head Somen Mishra are capable of backing nuanced, socially relevant stories that transcend the “Dharma mould.”
However, this artistic high was contrasted sharply by Nadaaniyan, the debut vehicle for Ibrahim Ali Khan and Khushi Kapoor.
The film became a lightning rod for “nepo-baby” criticism and was panned for its hollow narrative, proving that the old-school strategy of launching star kids through glossy romantic comedies no longer buys the audience’s affection. If Homebound was a strategic triumph of craft, Nadaaniyan felt like a legacy fluke that failed to read the room.
Similarly, Yash Raj Films experienced a year where the “bigger is better” mantra was turned on its head. The massive anticipation for War 2, directed by Ayan Mukerji, ultimately met a lukewarm reception. .
NTR, the film was weighed down by subpar VFX and a script that felt like a collection of action tropes rather than a cohesive story.
While it grossed over ₹300 crore, its astronomical budget and the “mixed-to-negative” critical consensus labelled it a commercial failure relative to its stakes, nearly derailing the momentum of the YRF Spy Universe.
In an ironic twist, YRF’s true “formula” success came from Saiyaara, a mid-budget musical romantic drama directed by Mohit Suri.
Launching newcomers Ahaan Panday and Aneet Padda, the film bypassed the “action fatigue” of the audience to become the highest-grossing Indian romantic film of all time, netting over ₹579 crore.
Saiyaara’s success was not a fluke but a return to the studio’s roots—soulful music and raw emotion—proving that the audience’s hunger for “heart” currently outweighs their appetite for hollow spectacle.
Ultimately, the trajectory of these films suggests that Dharma and YRF do not “know” what works in the definitive sense; rather, they are operating in a state of strategic experimentation.
The success of Homebound and Saiyaara indicates that when these studios empower distinct directorial voices like Ghaywan and Suri, they hit gold. Conversely, when they lean on the crutches of “brand extensions” or “pedigreed debuts,” as seen with War 2 and Nadaaniyan, they risk significant failure.
It isn’t all a fluke, but the “fluke” factor has certainly increased because the Indian audience has become more discerning and less loyal to production house labels.
The lesson of 2025 is that for a film to work today, the production house’s “bet” must be on the story’s resonance rather than the studio’s scale. The studios are learning that the safest bet is no longer the safest star, but the most sincere vision.
About the Author
